Player Ratings: Manchester City Leave It Late to Secure Vital 2-0 Win at Everton | OneFootball

Player Ratings: Manchester City Leave It Late to Secure Vital 2-0 Win at Everton | OneFootball

Icon: EPL Index

EPL Index

·19 April 2025

Player Ratings: Manchester City Leave It Late to Secure Vital 2-0 Win at Everton

Article image:Player Ratings: Manchester City Leave It Late to Secure Vital 2-0 Win at Everton

Late Surge Sees Manchester City Edge Past Everton in Premier League Battle

Manchester City’s visit to Goodison Park demanded patience, persistence and, ultimately, precision. For much of the contest, Pep Guardiola’s side were made to work hard by a disciplined Everton outfit. Yet, as so often with champions-in-waiting or contenders of elite pedigree, City found a way. Two late goals ensured a 2-0 victory and reinforced their push for a top-four Premier League finish.

Everton Frustrate Before Cracks Appear

Everton entered this contest with little in the way of expectation but offered far more than just resistance. They were organised, aggressive in key areas, and briefly threatened to steal momentum through a first-half header against the post and disciplined defensive shape.


OneFootball Videos


James Tarkowski marshalled the back line with authority, while Jake O’Brien impressed with a critical interception to deny what appeared to be a certain City opener. The midfield trio worked hard to disrupt City’s rhythm, and for over 80 minutes, that strategy held firm.

City Patience Turns into Precision

City, by contrast, were sluggish in the opening period, unable to find the tempo or incision that has so often defined their performances. Kevin De Bruyne probed, Savinho offered flashes of pace, and Omar Marmoush found occasional pockets of space, but Everton’s structure held.

As the game drifted towards its final act, City finally clicked into gear. Possession became pressure, pressure turned to openings, and the breakthrough arrived with a close-range finish from Nico O’Reilly that finally beat Jordan Pickford.

Article image:Player Ratings: Manchester City Leave It Late to Secure Vital 2-0 Win at Everton

Photo: IMAGO

With the hosts chasing the game late on, City found space and confidence. Mateo Kovacic’s composed strike from the edge of the box deep into stoppage time confirmed the points and wrapped up a result that looked far from certain an hour earlier.

Performance Reflects City’s Strategic Depth

It was not a vintage display from Manchester City. The midfield was pedestrian at times, and the build-up lacked variety early on. However, the ability to remain composed, make decisive substitutions, and adjust tempo when needed once again set them apart.

This was a win built on calm heads and tactical control rather than outright dominance. Stefan Ortega produced a composed display in goal, while the full-backs and midfield gradually asserted themselves as Everton tired.

The three points lift City back into the top four, adding pressure on their rivals ahead of a crucial run-in. The focus now shifts to consistency as the Premier League season approaches its climax.

Everton Effort Without End Product

Everton will be frustrated. This was a performance built on discipline and defensive resilience, undone only by a brief lapse in concentration and an inability to threaten consistently in the final third. Jordan Pickford was excellent between the posts, but the forward line lacked cohesion and conviction.

Armando Broja’s presence offered little threat, and while Iliman Ndiaye worked tirelessly on the flank, chances remained scarce. With survival still to be secured, Everton must now regroup and find a way to turn solid performances into results.

This match showed Everton can compete against top sides when organised, but as the margins narrow, so too does the room for error. Their Premier League safety remains in the balance, and time is running short.

Player Ratings

Everton

  • Jordan Pickford – 7.1
  • Jake O’Brien – 6.2
  • James Tarkowski – 7.6
  • Jarrad Branthwaite – 6.4
  • Vitalii Mykolenko – 6.7
  • James Garner – 7.1
  • Idrissa Gueye – 6.9
  • Jack Harrison – 6.6
  • Abdoulaye Doucoure – 6.4
  • Iliman Ndiaye – 7.2
  • Armando Broja – 5.9
  • Michael Keane (52’) – 6.2
  • Beto (73’) – 6.5
  • Tim Iroegbunam (79’) – 6.2
  • Carlos Alcaraz (79’) – 6.0
  • Dwight McNeil (79’) – 5.8
  • Subs not used: Joao Virginia, Ashley Young, Seamus Coleman, Nathan Patterson

Manchester City

  • Stefan Ortega – 8.5
  • Matheus Nunes – 8.1
  • Ruben Dias – 7.3
  • Josko Gvardiol – 7.3
  • Nico O’Reilly – 8.3
  • Ilkay Gundogan – 8.1
  • Nico Gonzalez – 6.5
  • Bernardo Silva – 6.9
  • Kevin De Bruyne – 6.8
  • Savinho – 7.6
  • Omar Marmoush – 6.9
  • Mateo Kovacic (78’) – 7.5
  • Jeremy Doku (78’) – 6.9
  • Manuel Akanji (88’) – N/A
View publisher imprint