Spurs Eye Manchester United Star as Transfer Window Pressure Mounts | OneFootball

Tottenham’s Pursuit of Garnacho: A Last-Ditch Gamble or a Bold Move?

Tottenham Hotspur’s attempt to sign Alejandro Garnacho from Manchester United marks another frantic chapter in their transfer window. After missing out on Bayern Munich’s Mathys Tel, Spurs turned their attention to the 20-year-old Argentine winger, but whether he would entertain a move to North London remains uncertain. The Daily Mail reports that United are open to selling for around £60 million, with Chelsea and Napoli also circling.

Spurs’ Transfer Strategy Under Scrutiny

Tottenham’s approach in the market has been a mix of ambition and last-minute desperation. Their initial move for Garnacho was reportedly a loan deal, a stark contrast to United’s stance of cashing in on the young winger. Given Spurs’ long-standing interest in the player, a more structured negotiation might have yielded better results.

Photo: IMAGO

Their interest in Garnacho was seemingly accelerated by the collapse of their £50m agreement with Bayern for Mathys Tel. The North London club had agreed on terms with Bayern, but discussions between Tel and his representatives proved to be the stumbling block. Tottenham chairman Daniel Levy was even spotted in Bavaria, actively attempting to finalise a deal before other Premier League clubs stepped in.

United Hold the Cards

For United, Garnacho’s situation is complex. Despite strong performances—such as his impactful substitute appearance in United’s 2-0 win over Steaua Bucharest—his future at Old Trafford is uncertain. With 121 appearances under his belt since debuting in 2022, the 20-year-old remains one of United’s brightest prospects. Yet, with Chelsea reportedly preparing a formal offer and Napoli previously testing United’s resolve with a £50m bid, the Red Devils are in a strong position to dictate terms.

The Daily Mail states: “Mail Sport reported last Thursday that Chelsea were putting forward a formal offer for Garnacho and that the Stamford Bridge outfit had a clear run at signing him, with Napoli switching their attention to Borussia Dortmund star Karim Adeyemi.”

Chelsea’s interest, along with Napoli’s persistence, could drive up the price. United’s response has been to slap a £65m valuation on Garnacho, making Spurs’ initial loan approach seem unrealistic.

Tottenham’s Injury Crisis and Transfer Dilemmas

One factor making Garnacho an attractive prospect for Tottenham is their ongoing injury crisis. Dominic Solanke is out for six weeks, while Wilson Odobert, Brennan Johnson, and Timo Werner are all sidelined. This has left Ange Postecoglou scrambling for reinforcements, but time is running out. Spurs need attacking depth, but convincing Garnacho to leave Old Trafford for a club currently in transition is another challenge altogether.

Personal terms often prove to be the most crucial stage of any transfer, and in Tel’s case, it became the final obstacle. The Daily Mail confirms: “With personal terms the final hurdle to get the transfer over the line, Tel rejected the move in the latest blow to Tottenham.” If Spurs are serious about Garnacho, they will need a compelling offer—not just financially, but in terms of his role in the squad.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

Spurs fans will likely feel concerned about their club’s transfer strategy. While Garnacho would be a great addition, Tottenham’s pattern of moving late in the window, often reacting rather than planning, is troubling. Their pursuit of Mathys Tel was promising, but the failure to secure him has exposed a lack of forward planning.

Meanwhile, United fans might be divided. On one hand, selling Garnacho would bring in significant funds, but on the other, losing a talented young winger to a domestic rival—especially Chelsea—could backfire. Garnacho has the potential to be a game-changer, and seeing him flourish elsewhere would sting.

For now, Spurs remain in a precarious position. If they fail to land Garnacho, they could be forced into a last-minute panic buy, something that has haunted them in past windows. Whether Garnacho himself even sees Tottenham as a step forward is another debate entirely.